Why Saudi Arabia Stands to Lose from Trump’s JCPOA Withdrawal
President Donald Trump announced on May 8 that the United States would withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal.
Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) was immediately condemned by many U.S. allies—particularly its European allies—but received enthusiastic support from Saudi Arabia.
Shortly after Trump’s speech, the Saudi Foreign Ministry expressed solidarity with the U.S. decision and urged the United States to impose stringent sanctions against Iran.
As Saudi Arabia remains embroiled in a struggle with Iran for regional hegemony, its support for Trump’s decision to withdraw from the JCPOA is unsurprising. However, a closer examination of the implications of Trump’s decision suggests that Saudi Arabia’s jubilation will be short-lived.
Trump’s withdrawal from the JCPOA could exacerbate latent tensions between Saudi Arabia and its regional allies; and embolden Iran to engage in aggressive policies that undercut Saudi Arabia’s security and weaken its regional influence.
The most immediate concern for Saudi Arabia is that Trump’s withdrawal from the JCPOA will weaken the cohesion of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC).
Since the outbreak of the Qatar crisis in June 2017, the GCC has been divided into two blocs over the acceptability of engagement with Iran. The GCC’s pro-isolation bloc, which includes Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Bahrain, believes that Iran is the primary source of instability in the Middle East and that Tehran must be contained at all costs.
The GCC’s pro-engagement bloc, which consists of Kuwait and Oman, echoes Saudi Arabia’s concerns about Iranian conduct but believes that selective cooperation and trade with Iran will benefit regional stability.
The chasm in perspectives between these two blocs has been revealed by Saudi Arabia and Kuwait’s divergent public statements about Iran and contrasting reactions to the growing Qatar-Iran partnership. While Saudi Arabia has stridently condemned Iran’s contribution to Iraq’s prolonged state of political instability, Kuwait has been reluctant to make sweeping criticisms of Iranian conduct and has praised Iran’s anti-ISIS efforts in Iraq.
Regarding Qatar, Saudi Arabia has viewed Doha’s strengthened partnership with Tehran as a justification for a continued blockade against the besieged emirate. However, Kuwait has insisted that the Qatar-Iran alignment should not preclude Doha’s normalization of relations with the rest of the GCC.
The United States’ withdrawal from the JCPOA could convince Saudi Arabia to pressure Kuwait and Oman to abandon their links with Iran, as Riyadh might view Washington’s shifting policy towards Iran as an opportunity to strengthen its hegemony over the GCC. After all, Kuwait and Oman are long-standing U.S. allies that are actively involved in mediating regional crises, both countries will be confident in their ability to avoid being punished for trading with Iran and to resist Saudi pressure.
If Kuwait and Oman refuse to bow to Saudi pressure, the gap in policies towards Iran between both blocs of the GCC will continue to grow. These divisions could greatly weaken the GCC’s effectiveness as a collective security organization.
As the recently signed alternative Saudi Arabia-UAE bilateral security pact has been undercut by the UAE’s occupation of the Yemeni island of Socotra, an inter-bloc schism within the GCC over Iran could leave Riyadh diplomatically isolated in its own sphere of influence.
In addition to undermining the cohesion of the GCC, the increased unpredictability of Iranian conduct associated with a JCPOA withdrawal poses a grave threat to Saudi Arabia’s security and geopolitical aspirations.
As Trump’s policies towards Iran have fuelled anti-American sentiments amongst the Iranian public, the political influence of conservative nationalists in Iran who are nostalgic for the Mahmoud Ahmadinejad era of contestation with the West has grown in recent months.
The strengthened influence of these hardline factions could convince Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei to escalate Iran’s belligerence to prevent Ahmadinejad and other hardliners from instigating mass protests, like those that broke out in late December.
An escalation of Iranian belligerence will undercut Saudi Arabia’s security, because Yemen is likely to be the first area where Iran will flex its military muscles.
Just hours after Trump’s withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal, Iran-backed Houthi rebels in Yemen fired missiles into Riyadh, which were successfully intercepted by the Saudi military.
This act of belligerence was widely interpreted as a form of retaliation from Iran for Saudi Arabia’s support for Trump’s withdrawal from the JCPOA.